IADR Abstract Archives

Analysis of OHP in South African Health Policy Development

Objectives: The central aim and objective of this research was to critically analyse oral health promotion (OHP) elements within health policies in post-apartheid South Africa and determine the extent of their implementation. Methods: The study used data source triangulation to construct a multilevel conceptual framework for data collection and analysis, collecting a combination of quantitative data and qualitative information on health service management and decision-making. The national and provincial directorates in Oral Health, Mental Health, Chronic Diseases and Disabilities, Health Promotion, Maternal Health, Child and Women's Health, Nutrition, HIV/Aids and STDs formed the study sample.

Results: The results indicate distinct contradictions in oral health promotion-related policy statements and decision-making. Only 50% of the 15 national health policy documents examined had statements on oral health or OHP. Two (17%) of the twelve provincial health policy documents reviewed made references to OHP. Fourteen provincial health managers (40%, n=35) indicated that their programmes included a viable OHP element of some kind.

Health policy development appears to follow an underlying vertical process despite efforts to project this process as an integrated effort. The health policy process also appears to be dominated by power, protection of professional interests and maintenance of autonomy. Potential opportunities to integrate health service delivery have not been adequately explored. Failure to translate policy rhetoric on OHP into pragmatic policy formulations or implementable strategies will continue to perpetuate health inequalities in South Africa. Conclusion: The study concludes that to successfully influence the processes of OHP requires more than simple, document-based policy reforms that are strong on rhetoric and good ideas, but have not achieved the widespread stakeholder support necessary to carry them through to funding and implementation. OHP strategies need to be re-assessed and re-structured so that real gains in dental public health can be attained.


Division: South African Division
Meeting: 2006 South African Division (Midrand, South Africa)
Location: Midrand, South Africa
Year: 2006
Final Presentation ID:
Abstract Category|Abstract Category(s): Scientific Groups
Authors
  • Singh, Shenuka  ( KZN Provincial Health, Durban, N/A, South Africa )
  • SESSION INFORMATION
    Oral Session
    Community Dentistry