IADR Abstract Archives

Translating Research Documents for Legislative Compliance and Promotion of Participation

The “Fluoride and Caring for Children’s Teeth” (FACCT) study includes measurement of dental caries and enamel fluorosis in a representative sample of school-children in the Republic of Ireland. The Official Languages Act 2003 promotes Irish for official purposes. English is much more widely spoken.

Objective:

To construct and utilise Irish language versions of the fieldwork documents, including the validated Parental-Caregiver Perceptions Questionnaire (P-CPQ) and Child Perceptions Questionnaire (CPQ11-14).

Method:

FACCT documents (introductory letter, consent form, residential and medical history form, parent survey) were professionally translated from English to Irish by University College Cork. The translated documents were verified independently and in duplicate by FACCT study personnel to confirm that the questions were unchanged by translation.

In the case of the validated instruments (P-CPQ and CPQ11-14) an additional safeguard was introduced, the questionnaires being back-translated by a second professional translator blind to the original English version. The original English versions and the back translated versions were then compared. The Irish wording was adjusted where necessary ensuring the meaning of the validated instruments was unchanged.

Result:

The FACCT sample (276 schools) includes 15 (5.4%) Gaelscoileanna (Irish-medium schools located in predominantly English-speaking regions) and 12 (4.3%) schools located in the Gaeltacht (Irish-speaking areas defined by government order). Eleven (73.3%) Gaelscoileanna requested English consent packs and 4 (26.7%) requested dual language consent packs. In Gaeltacht areas, 2 schools (16.7%) requested Irish consent packs; 5 (41.7%) requested dual language consent packs and 5 (41.7%) requested English consent packs. The Irish and English CPQ11-14 was administered electronically; the Irish CPQ11-14   was completed by 35 12-year-olds in 6 Gaelscoileanna. 

Conclusion:

When conducting research surveys in a bilingual country, considerable resources are expended in complying with legislation and promoting participation of individuals who speak the minority official language.

Division: Pan European Region Meeting
Meeting: 2014 Pan European Region Meeting (Dubrovnik, Croatia)
Location: Dubrovnik, Croatia
Year: 2014
Final Presentation ID: 604
Abstract Category|Abstract Category(s): Scientific Groups
Authors
  • James, Patrice  ( University College Cork, Cork, , Ireland )
  • Beecher, Tara  ( University College Cork, Cork, , Ireland )
  • Harding, Mairead  ( University College Cork, Cork, , Ireland )
  • Whelton, Helen  ( University of Leeds, Leeds, , England )
  • SESSION INFORMATION
    Poster Session
    Results of Health Services
    09/13/2014