Objectives: The aim of this study was to evaluate in vitro the influence of fibre-reinforcement and luting cement on the resistance to peel loading and fatigue loading of cantilever resin-bonded fixed partial dentures (RBFPDs). Methods: Beams (1mm thick, 2mm wide, and 25mm long) made of particulate filler composite (PFC) Filtek Z100 (3M Espe) or fibre-reinforced composite (FRC) Everstick C&B (Sticktech Ltd) simulating two-unit cantilever RBFPDs were luted with Panavia F 2.0, (Kuraray) and RelyX ARC (3M Espe) to the enamel of flat ground bovine teeth. The fatigue resistance was investigated with a newly opened package of fibres (new FRC) and with fibres which were stored at 4ºC in air for 6 month in the dark (aged FRC). Fracture resistance (n=8) was obtained in a universal testing machine. Fatigue testing (n=15) was performed by subjecting the specimens to a rotating cantilever beam test (104cycle, 1.2Hz) according the staircase' approach. Results: ANOVA revealed that fibre-reinforcement and luting cement had significant effect (P<0.05) on fracture and fatigue resistance. Luting cement had no statistical significant effect (P>0.05) on fracture and fatigue resistance of FRC beams. The fatigue resistance of the new FRCs was significantly higher than the aged FRCs.
|
Fracture resistance (N) |
Fatigue resistance (N) |
|
new FRC |
aged FRC |
||
Z100 - Panavia F2.0 |
2.46a(0.28) |
0.60d(0.08) |
|
Z100 RelyX ARC |
3.76b(0.23) |
0.84e(0.11) |
|
Everstick Panavia F2.0 |
5.19c(1.12) |
2.12f(0.02) |
1.40g(0.09) |
Everstick RelyX ARC |
5.22c(1.16) |
2.09f(0.02) |
1.46g(0.03) |
Conclusion: PFC beams showed highest fracture and fatigue resistance when low E-modulus resin luting cement was used. It was concluded that highest fracture resistance, fatigue resistance were obtained with FRC beams, but it is recommend to use a newly opened package.