IADR Abstract Archives

Usability of the EGOHID-II Oral Health Clinical Indicators Survey Form

Objectives: To quantify the ease/difficulties experienced by European General Dental Practitioners (GDPs) in conducting European Global Oral Health Indicators Development (EGOHID) oral health surveys during routine general practice.

Methods: 146 dentists in 9 countries were recruited, by local coordinators, to pilot a system for the uniform, Europe-wide collection of dental surveillance data. Generally, two half days of training were used to introduce the volunteers to the “Oral Health Clinical Indicators Survey Form“, before returning to their practices with a target of examining 20 patients each. The survey form included eight clinical sections though completion of some was patient's-age-dependent. In two countries half of the dentists examined soft-tissue only and the remainder examined hard-tissues [fluorosis and International Caries Detection and Assessment System (ICDAS) caries score]. Dentists also completed questionnaires following each patient's assessment (green) indicating their personal level of difficulty in completing each clinical section, and another (mauve) indicating, after all patients, the acceptability to them of the examination in general.

Results: 2,016 green post-patient questionnaires and 102 mauve overall questionnaires were returned (69.1% of target). The percentage of dentists claiming little/no difficulty ranged from 72.1% - 99.5% across the eight clinical sections. Mean examination time (minutes) varied by section, e.g. 1.25 (orthodontic treatment), 10.67 (ICDAS), and 12.47 (Loss of Attachment + Community Periodontal Index). In the free comments section of the mauve questionnaires, 54% indicated worries about time taken away from treatment time. Recording loss of attachment was noted as a particular concern, due to the time taken and unfamiliarity with the measure.

Conclusions: European GDPs reported little difficulty in conducting the oral health surveys but many felt the time taken was burdensome. It is concluded that GDPs can be used to carry out survey work in addition to their routine practice provided that the time taken is considered appropriately.


Division: British Division Meeting
Meeting: 2009 British Division Meeting (Glasglow, Scotland)
Location: Glasglow, Scotland
Year: 2009
Final Presentation ID: 181
Abstract Category|Abstract Category(s): Scientific Groups
Authors
  • Bonner, Brian C.  ( Dental Health Services Research Unit, Dundee, N/A, United Kingdom )
  • Pitts, Nigel B.  ( Dental Health Services Research Unit, Dundee, N/A, United Kingdom )
  • Topping, Gail Va  ( Dental Health Services Research Unit, Dundee, N/A, United Kingdom )
  • Bourgeois, Denis  ( Université Claude Bernard Lyon, Lyon, N/A, France )
  • SESSION INFORMATION
    Poster Session
    Health Services
    09/03/2009