To measure push-out bond strengths (PBS) of pairs of luting systems from the same manufacturer to root dentin.
Methods:
Dowel spaces were prepared with RelyX Fiber Post (RXP, 3M ESPE) drills in 60 endodontically-treated human monoradicular teeth. Teeth were randomly assigned to a luting system (n=10): MCO - AdheSE DC/Multicore Flow (Ivoclar Vivadent); MLI - Multilink Primer/Multilink Automix (Ivoclar Vivadent); PCO - ParaBond/ ParaCore (Coltene); PCE - ParaBond/ParaCem Universal DC (Coltene); RUL - Scotchbond Universal Adhesive (self-etch)/RelyX Ultimate (3M ESPE); RUN - RelyX Unicem 2 Automix (3M ESPE). RXPs (3M ESPE) were used for all groups.
Roots were sectioned in three 2.0±0.1mm-thick slices: Cervical (C), Middle (M), and Apical (A). Each slice was tested in a universal testing machine at a crosshead speed of 1.0 mm/min applied to the post center until failure. PBS were calculated by dividing the minimum force for rupture the bond by the area of the interface (conical frustum). A two-way ANOVA/Fisher’s LSD multiple comparison test (p<0.05) were computed.
Results:
(MPa±SD)
|
C |
M |
A |
MCO |
41.29±32.9AB |
54.04±25.1B |
56.78±26.6C |
MLI |
28.06±28.5A |
15.97±7.9A |
15.65±13.4A |
PCO |
50.93±33.5AB |
49.61±35.7B |
41.94±32.2BC |
PCE |
43.08±13.6AB |
35.88±13.3AB |
27.34±23.0AB |
RUL |
59.36±33.0B |
55.82±29.3B |
48.11±17.2BC |
RUN |
58.62±31.5B |
43.13±30.5B |
50.15±31.2BC |
Columns: means with the same superscript letter are not statistically different. |
|||
For all root thirds, the luting systems that include a buildup composite (MCO and PCO) resulted in higher mean PBS than their counterpart luting systems that included a resin cement (MLI and PCE). The self-adhesive cement RUN and the self-etch luting system RUL resulted in similar mean PBS. MLI resulted in the lowest mean bond strength, especially at the M and A root thirds.
Conclusion:
Buildup composite resins combined with the recommended adhesive may be used to lute fiber posts. The self-adhesive cement RUN performed at the same level as the self-etch resin cement RUL.