Methods: Using arbitrarily-primed polymerase chain reaction (AP-PCR), MS genotypes were developed from nine pediatric patients undergoing caries preventive therapy, including restoration, antimicrobial rinse and fluoride varnish. Plaque was collected pre- and post-treatment (2-4 weeks), and MS strains were isolated by bacitracin selection, subjected to AP-PCR for assignment within genotypic groups, and characterized for acidogenesis and acid tolerance.
Results: Inter-patient variability in genotypes was high, but with selected patients, intra-patient variability was low between the pre- and post-treatment collections, with some genotypes undergoing significant shifts in number. One genotype (GB) in patient G increased from 14% to 78% of the population following treatment, and was highly acidogenic, yielding a pH of 4.368 (n=39; SE=0.017) after 3 days of growth in phenol red dextrose. Control S. mutans strains UA159, ATCC 25175 and ATCC 35668 generated pH values of 4.67-4.89 (n=4; SE<0.07). Another genotype (KD) in patient K increased from 2% to 24% of the population following treatment, and was highly acid-tolerant, with an acid tolerance (AT) index of 0.858 (n=14; SE=0.124). The AT index is defined by bacterial numbers surviving treatment at pH 2.8 divided by bacterial numbers surviving at pH 7.0.
Conclusions: Caries preventive therapy resulted in population increases of highly acidogenic or acid-tolerant MS strains. The implications are that caries preventive therapy may not always eliminate MS strains with high cariogenic potential, and that well-accepted practices for caries prevention should be more closely examined for efficacy.
Supported by OCTRI and OHSU School of Dentistry.