IADR Abstract Archives

31P solid-state NMR investigation of compounds in phosphate-bonded investments (PBI's)

Objective: Although PBI's are extensively used to produce dental castings little has been published on their chemistry. This is surprising since some chemistry dependent effects, important to performance, are poorly controlled. The objective was to identify phosphorus containing matrix compounds.

Methods: A small but representative range (n=5) of commercial products was investigated in the as-received, green-set and burnt-out conditions. They were mixed according to manufacturer's instructions using undiluted special liquid. Structures were investigated by 31P MAS-NMR with high-powered-decoupling and/or cross-polarisation.

Results: As received, a single 31P resonance peak was observed at either 0ppm on the NMR spectrum [≡ pure (NH4H2PO4)] or ≈-2ppm (additive displaced orthophosphate). Green-set produced the expected orthophosphate struvite peak (MgNH4PO4.6H2O) at +6ppm, but also a second major orthophosphate peak (+1ppm to +3ppm) and in some products a minor pyrophosphate peak. Burn-out at the recommended temperature created spectra with between two and six peaks, no two being the same. Two PBI's intended for base alloys had a dominant pyrophosphate peak (-5ppm or -8ppm) with a minor presence of orthophosphate (+2ppm or +3ppm). A third had a dominant orthophosphate peak (0ppm) with significant metaphosphate peaks (-13ppm and -19ppm). Two PBI's intended for precious alloys had metphosphate main peaks (-13ppm to -22ppm) with a presence of orthophosphate (-1ppm to +2ppm). Traces of struvite persisted after burn-out. Silicophosphate was not detected.

Conclusions: Chemistries are complex and variable. Struvite and unreacted NH4H2PO4 can account for the green-set orthphosphate peaks (pyrophosphate, possibly nucleation seeds). Proposition - under appropriate conditions, Mg(PO3)2 is formed during the thermal decomposition of MgNH4PO4.H2O as an alternative to the assumed product Mg2P2O7, and that Mg2P2O7 can react with MgO to form Mg3(PO4). To dismiss silicophosphate formation completely, an additional experiment must be conducted due to the possibility of a very long relaxation time.

(Scottish executive Grant CZG/4/1/10).


IADR/AADR/CADR General Session
2005 IADR/AADR/CADR General Session (Baltimore, Maryland)
Baltimore, Maryland
2005
2582
Dental Materials: VIII - Others-Non-metallic
  • Scrimgeour, Sheelagh Nicoll  ( University of Dundee, Dundee, N/A, United Kingdom )
  • Chudek, John Alexander  ( University of Dundee, Dundee, N/A, United Kingdom )
  • Lochhead, Karen  ( University of Dundee, Dundee, N/A, United Kingdom )
  • Lloyd, Charles Heywood  ( University of Dundee, Dundee, N/A, United Kingdom )
  • Oral Session
    Special Topics
    03/12/2005