Effect of cement type and CAD-CAM material on the retention of ceramic crowns supported by zirconia abutments.
Objectives: The purpose of this in-vitro study was to investigate the effect of cement type and CAD-CAM restorative material on the retention properties of ceramic crowns supported by zirconia abutments. Methods: A total of 128 crowns were milled from four different restorative materials (IPS e-max CAD-IPS, Vita Suprinity-VS, Vita Enamic-VE and Vita YZ ST-ST)(n=32/group). Crowns were cemented on custom zirconia abutments with either interim cement (Temp Bond-TP), resin-modified glass-ionomer cement (FujiCEM II- FC), self-adhesive cement (RelyX Unicem 2-RX) or adhesive cement (Panavia F 2-PF) (n=8/subgroup), under a load of 5 kg. Test specimens were thermally cycled (5-55°C) for 500 cycles with a dwell time of 30s. The retention properties of the crowns were tested in a universal testing machine by applying a separation force at a cross-head speed of 1.0 mm/min in vertical direction and the maximum force leading to decementation was determined. The obtained data were statistically compared using two-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) and Post-Hoc Tukey HSD tests. Statistical significance was determined at p<.05. Results: Significant interactions between cement type and CAD/CAM restorative material were observed (p<.05, Table 1). Adhesive cements (RX and PF) showed higher retention values than interim (TB) or resin-modified glass-ionomer cement (FC). The VS crowns presented the highest retention values while ST crowns showed the lowest values (p < 0.05, Table 2). Conclusions: The retentive properties of implant supported crowns were affected by the type of CAD-CAM restorative material used for prosthetic restoration and cement selection.
IADR/AADR/CADR General Session
2019 IADR/AADR/CADR General Session (Vancouver, BC, Canada) Vancouver, BC, Canada
2019 0654.1 Dental Materials 1: Ceramic-based Materials
Sermet, Bulent
( Istanbul Universitry Faculty of Dentistry
, Istanbul
, Turkey
)
Ozcan, Erkin
( Istanbul Universitry Faculty of Dentistry
, Istanbul
, Turkey
)
Sen, Nazmiye
( Istanbul Universitry Faculty of Dentistry
, Istanbul
, Turkey
)
Ongul, Deger
( Istanbul Universitry Faculty of Dentistry
, Istanbul
, Turkey
)
Research fund of Istanbul University as project number TSA-2018-31940.
NONE.
Poster Session
Clinical Research on Ceramics
Thursday,
06/20/2019
, 11:00AM - 12:15PM
Table 1: Two-way analysis of variance (ANOVA)
Source
Type III Sum of Squares
df
Mean square
F
Sig.
Corrected model
27346.065a
4
8109.065
152.821
0.000
Intercept
3124.102
1
3124.102
32.459
0.029
Restorative material
689.135
1
689.135
86.075
0.000
Cement type
79.146
1
79.146
9.005
0.017
Restorative material * Cement type
259.847
1
259.847
29.103
0.000
Error
19846.703
64
97.146
Total
769589.000
79
Corrected total
386705.000
75
Two-way analysis of variance superscript letter. P values, a=.05. aR2, .875 (adjusted R2, .863).
Table 2: Results of pull-out strength test.
Retention Force (N)
Interim cement
Resin-modified glass-ionomer cement
Self-adhesive cement
Adhesive cement
Materials
TB
FC
RX
PF
IPS
67±9a
106±17b
261±25e
312±54e,f
VE
96±14b
187±34c,d
205±21d
274±26e
VS
102±11b
137±19c
349±57f
375±43f
YZ-ST
49±6a
82±16a
151±19c
237±34d
*Same superscript letters represent groups with no statistically significant (P>.05) differences according to Post-Hoc Tukey HSD tests.